English

There lies a great difference between text book medicine and the world of practising physician. Discuss.

Advertisements
Advertisements

Question

There lies a great difference between text book medicine and the world of practising physician. Discuss.

Answer in Brief
Advertisements

Solution

A model answer has been provided for students' reference.

It is strongly recommended that students prepare the answer on their own.

There lies a great difference between text book medicine and the world of practising physician. Text book medicine is purely a Science whereas treating a patient is an art. The world of practising physician requires a different set of skills and knowledge. Text book medicine no doubt provides the conceptual framework for treatment but no doctor can treat a patient without the use of his or her intuitive practices. In the story Birth the way Andrew brings back life in the still born child is a testimony to this fact. The nurse at first dumps the child thinking it to be dead. But Andrews takes a chance and the miracle happens. He in the beginning applies his text book knowledge but the child does not recover. He doesnot lose heart. He applies his own intuitive method and the miracle then happened. Treatment is Science and beyond. It is both a science and an art. The story Birth is a realistic fiction. In other words, the elements of the story has been taken from real life experiences and woven in the fabric of fiction.

shaalaa.com
Reading Skills
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
Chapter 4: Birth - Reading with insight [Page 38]

APPEARS IN

NCERT English Snapshots (Core) Class 11
Chapter 4 Birth
Reading with insight | Q 2. | Page 38

RELATED QUESTIONS

What inference can you draw from the action of the female gorilla described in para 2 ? 


Read the following passage and complete the activities given below:

A1. Name the following: With reference to the passage.
(i) Two people who influenced Mashelkar ________.
(ii) The trust which granted a scholarship to Mashelkar _______.
(iii) The Director of the Board of Tata Motors _______.
(iv) Principal Bhave demonstrated _______.
 
In fact, I remember, my passing the SSC Examination – i.e. 11th standard. Those days it used to be not 10th standard or 12th standard but 11th standard. I stood 11th among 1,35,000 but I was about to leave higher education and find a job. What helped me was the scholarship by Sir Dorab Tata Trust. It was just 60 rupees per month and would you believe that 60 rupees per month from Tatas added so much value to my life that I have been able to stand here today before you to speak to you.
I am on the Board of Tatas now and it is very interesting that the same Bombay House where I used to go to collect that 60 rupees per month now one goes and sits there as a Director on the Board of Tata Motors. The turn that these 40 years have taken is very interesting. It has all been possible because of the chance I got to do higher studies at the insistence of my mother. She gave me the values of my life. She was one of the noblest parents I have met in my life. So, my greatest guru was my mother. My second great guru was Principal Bhave, about whom I made a mention earlier. He taught us Physics. Because it was a poor school, I remember, it had to innovate to convey to the young students the message of Science. I still remember one of the interesting experiences when, on a Friday afternoon, Principal Bhave took us out into the sun to demonstrate to us how to find the focal length of a convex lens. He had a piece of paper here, a convex lens here and he moved it up and down and there was a point when there were a sharp focus and a bright spot on the paper.
He showed the distance between the paper and the lens and said that this distance was the focal length. But then the paper started burning. For some reason, he then turned to me, and said, “Mashelkar, if you focus your energies like this, you can burn anything in the world.”
 
A2. Supply the information from the passage.
(i) Mashelkar could continue his studies because ________.
(ii) The teaching of Principal Bhave’s experiment was ________.
(iii) Mashelkar considers his mother as the greatest Guru because ________.
(iv) The paper started burning because ________.
 
A3 Word Register (from the passage) 
Prepare a word register for the word Education
 
A4 Modal Auxiliary
(i) I used to go to collect 60 rupees per month.
(Rewrite the sentence using Modal Auxiliary ‘would’)
(ii) Reported Speech:
Principal Bhave said, “Mashelkar if you focus your energies like this, you can burn anything in the world.”
(How will Mashelkar report this to his friend?)
 
A5 Personal Response
What is the role played by our parents in shaping our careers?

List the steps taken by the captain

(i) to protect the ship when rough weather began.

(ii) to check the flooding of the water in the ship.


Describe the shifts in the narration of the events as indicated in the three sections of the text. Give a subtitle to each section.


Briefly explain the following statement from the text.

“You neither travelled to the past nor the future. You were in the present experiencing a different world.”


What is the central argument of the speaker?


What does the line 'I never writ, nor no man ever loved' imply?


Explain the phrase.

Time's fool


Discuss in pairs or in small groups
The description of novels as organisms.


'He is free to play the flute all day as well-fed tigers and fat sheep drink from the same pond

with a full stomach for a common bond.'

What do the phrases 'play the flute all day' and 'a common bond' refer to?


Read the story and complete the following.

Revathi’s grief knew no bounds because, ____________.


Answer in your own words.

How did the plants respond when Revathi played her favourite tune?


Read the Preamble of the Constitution of India given in your textbook. Pick out a word that refers to the following.

Brotherhood 


Pick out some sentences from the lesson that convey a general truth.


Answer the given question in your own words.

What decision did the Swallow finally make? Was it a wise one? Comment.


Pick out a word from the poem to complete the sentence meaningfully.

Stephen Hawking was a ______ (famous) Astrophysicist. 


Write any five illnesses of the animals in the poem that you find most amusing / laughable.


Discuss in your class.

Are robots truly useful to human beings? Why? Why not?


Write about how your family supports you to go to school.


How many of them are personal articles? How many of them are used for the beautification of your home? How many of them are meant for utility (to fulfill a useful function in the household)?


Can you name different types of fabrics? Which is the most expensive fabric you know? Talk to your parents or to a textile shop assistant. Collect samples of as many types as you can and paste them into your scrapbook. Name each type.


Choose the odd one out :

Bottom, Moth, Mustardseed, Cobweb.


Shakespeare is acknowledged as the greatest writer because he understood human nature better than anyone else. Explain the statement in the context of the play.


Portia saved Antonio in the court of law.


Write the following in short:

The story of the three caskets.


An activity:
Speak fast, think faster ! Form groups of 4-6. Discuss each of the following topics. Then each person in the group should choose a topic and speak about it for one minute. Try to say as many sentences as you can in that time.

What may happen...

I may study... A bird may fly into the classroom. The Principal may call me... It may rain... A dog may chase a cat... A king may lose his kingdom... My friend may give me a storybook to read... Mother may make idlis today...’ etc.


Write a short note on the following:

The ‘four signs’ that Prince Siddharth beheld.


Write the meaning of doth.


We find the following in the script of a skit or play. Rearrange these steps in the proper order and write them down in the form of a flow chart.


Read: ‘The Psalm of Life’- a poem by H. W. Longfellow.


Read aloud a couple of stanzas of the poem ‘Invictus’ and ‘Please Listen’. In what ways do they differ? Think and fill up the table with ‘Yes’ or ‘No’.

  Invictus Please Listen
Rhyming lines ______ ______
Steady rhythm ______ ______
Uniformity in the length of lines ______ ______
Uniformity of the number of lines in each stanza. ______ ______
Figurative language ______ ______

Name the following.

Pounced on Dhyan Chand and hurt him.


Read the word. Write the words that combine to make it.

footprint


Guess the meaning of the following word.

coarse grained 


Identify the character or speaker.

He was the chief of all spirits.


What woke up the mother?


How were offerings carried during the ancient period?


Who was the first person to withdraw cash from the ATM?


Write about Hamid in one or two sentences.


What did Usha see while walking to the bazaar?


What kind of learning brings joy to you?


Did he hire Kiouni? Why?


Write a paragraph about 50 words describing the scenes that the poet passed by.


Gulliver was the captain of the ship.


How should one react to adversity?


What kind of a boy was Vicky?


Answer using Yes or No and pick sentence from the story to support your answer.

Did Robinson kill Friday?


Who is the hero of this story?


Like whom did they want to do?


Circle and write the adverbs.

I drink coffee thrice a day. ______


Tenzin is from ______.


Why it is important for people to live without boundaries?


Jana saw a _______ behind her.


Read the passage three times and colour a dustbin each time.

I am Mani. I had to take a bus to nearby city. I crossed the road to reach the bus stand. I got the bus, sat down, and read a book. Before I started to read, I just looked at the people around me. The two men sitting next to me were talking loudly. Some were listening to music on their phone. I was unable to focus on reading. The men were talking about cleaning the city. As they were talking, they opened a pack of biscuits to eat. After some time I dozed off. When I opened my eyes, the bus had reached the city. The two men were not there but pieces of the biscuits and wrappers were there. I cleaned the wrappers and put them in the dustbin.

  1. What did Mani take out?
  2. What did Mani find on the seat when he woke up?
  3. If you were Mani, what would you do?

Match with their storing places.


Read the passage 3 times and colour the medal each time.

The school was decorated for the Annual Sports Day. The children came to the running track to cheer the runners. The next event was 800 meters running. Megala was in the race. She wanted to win the race, but the other runners were district and divisional winners. The race started. All had to finish two laps. At the end of the first lap, Megala was in the fifth place. Suddenly, she fell on the ground. Everyone ran to help her. But before that she got up and started to run. All children and teachers cheered her. She had come last, but the headmaster gave her a special prize.


What secrets did he learn about beasts?


Did the girl buy a picture book?


Collect the outer coverings of fast food items. Discuss the following points in groups and then write your observations in your notebook.

  • Ingredients
  • Manufactured by
  • Net weight
  • Veg or Non-veg
  • Recipe
  • Nutrition facts
  • MRP
  • Mfg date
  • Website
  • Other instructions, if any

Being a bachelor, the stranger had no patience with children.


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×