English

What is the central argument of the speaker? - English Elective - NCERT

Advertisements
Advertisements

Question

What is the central argument of the speaker?

Answer in Brief
Advertisements

Solution

A In the essay patterns of creativity, S. Chandrasekhar tries to figure out the reason for the difference in the patterns of creativity among the practitioners in the arts and practitioners in the sciences. He did not answer it, rather, he made an assortment of remarks that bore the answer. He cites examples explaining how poets and scientists view each other defining the difference in their views. There are poets such as Wordsworth and Keats who are worshippers of nature, who believe that humans sabotage nature by the technological advancement. However, there are poets like Shelley, who do poetry on science. It is difficult to segregate the views and put them into water tight compartments. Darwin, for instance enjoyed literature immensely as it gave him utmost joy, but only till the age of 30. W. B. Yeats, in praise of Shelley's A Defence of Poetry, called it the profoundest essay on the foundation of poetry in the English language The author of the essay, Chandrasekhar wonders in the end that why is there no such A Defence of Science written by a scientist of equal endowment. Perhaps the answer to the question he knew already.

shaalaa.com
Reading Skills
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
Chapter 3.2: My Three Passions - Understanding the text [Page 151]

APPEARS IN

NCERT English (Elective) - Woven Words
Chapter 3.2 My Three Passions
Understanding the text | Q 5 | Page 151

RELATED QUESTIONS

Answer any four of the following in 30 − 40 words each :

(a) What does Saheb look for in the garbage dumps?

(b) How was Gandhi treated at Rajendra Prasad's house?

(c) Why does one feel 'a sudden strangeness' on counting to twelve and keeping quiet?

(d) Mention any two things which cause pain and suffering. (A Thing of Beauty)

(e) When was the Tiger King in danger of losing his throne?

(f) What role did the American professor play in bringing Hana and Sadao together?


Answer any four of the following questions in 30 - 40 words each :
(a) What kind of gold did the people of Seemapuri look for in the garbage ? (Lost Spring)
(b) Why did Gandhi tell the court that he was involved in a 'conflict of duties' ?
(c) How do we get joy from life which is otherwise full of sorrows ? (A Thing of Beauty)
(d) For Aunt Jennifer, what do the tigers symbolise ?
(e) What made the chief astrologer place his finger on his nose ? (The Tiger King)
(f) On the seventh day after the American soldier was found by Dr. Sadao two things happened. Why did Hana feel scared of the second ?


Chimps making their own fishing rods is an indication that 


Look for pictures in newspapers and magazines that depict the urban civic problems discussed in the text. Cut them out and pin them to the text at appropriate places.


What does the phrase 'as if he were on needles' mean? Can you think of another phrase with a similar meaning substituting the word 'needless'?


What impression would you form of a state where the King was 'just and placid'?


'New Literature' is a misnomer for the wealth of the Indian Literary tradition. How does G. N. Devy explain this?


Explain the undertones in the statement:

'Wife and husband in unusual rapport

State one unspoken thought':


'Trees are sacred my grandmother used to say'– what does the poet imply by this line?


Find proof from the poem for the following.

The poet’s minute observations of the steady growth of the cherry tree.


In our country engineering, teaching, and medical fields are much sought after. Other professions, occupations though they make a significant contribution to society, do not get their due.

(a) Farmer highly unpredictable economic gains
(b) Conservancy workers ________________
(c) ________________ ________________
(d) ________________ ________________
(e) ________________ ________________

Using points from the lesson, give the details of the following in a short paragraph.

International Kite Festival at Ahmedabad.


Read the lesson and name the following.

A sack around the heart ______


Match the professions with the field of work.

  Profession   Field of work
(1) Chief Minister (a) Business
(2) Magistrate (b) Transport
(3) Soldier (c) Construction
(4) Trader (d) Administration
(5) Builder (e) Education
(6) Driver (f) Defence
(7) Teacher (g) Law

Discuss with your teacher how/why are ‘stars’ given to a movie.


Draw a diagram to show a volcanic eruption from its description given in this passage. Label the diagram. Show the following in it :

Volcano; earth’s crust; crack in the earth’s crust; hot molten rock; red, hot lava; smoke; ash; burning chunks of rock.


Answer the following question in one sentence.

Who misses all the fun?


Choose any one of the seven States. Find more information about it and prepare a leaflet or brochure to invite people to visit it. 


If you saw someone abusing an animal, what would you do? Write about it in 5 lines.


Read the following.

  1. I mean what I say. I say what I mean.
  2. I see what I eat. I eat what I see.

Use your imagination to write a funny sentence on this pattern.


Sayali made a hasty purchase.


Discuss:
In the story, human settlements are mentioned but not cities or villages. Why is it so? 


Form groups of 4. Find all the references to the time given in the passage. Then make a chart to show the events described in the passage along with the time when they occur. Example:

All night long: The crew stayed on their feet.
Near midnight: ________________________
At 12.53: ________________________

(Use as many lines as you need.)


Read: ‘The Listeners’ and ‘Someone’ - poems by Walter de la Mare. 


Rewrite in your own words.

One event from the story. 


Write your own impressions about the news items given in (a), (b), (c), and (d) in the table below. 

News item Good news Bad news Reliable Unreliable Interesting Uninteresting Boring Others
(a)        
(b)        
(c)        
(d)        

Rohan desperately wished for ______.


Rohan had finished ______ rounds of the tree before Mrs. Groover discovered him.


Read aloud a couple of stanzas of the poem ‘Invictus’ and ‘Please Listen’. In what ways do they differ? Think and fill up the table with ‘Yes’ or ‘No’.

  Invictus Please Listen
Rhyming lines ______ ______
Steady rhythm ______ ______
Uniformity in the length of lines ______ ______
Uniformity of the number of lines in each stanza. ______ ______
Figurative language ______ ______

Name the following.

Ruler of Germany.


Read the following line from the poem and answer the question that follow.

So let the way wind up the hill or down, O'er rough or smooth, the journey will be joy: Still seeking what I sought when but a boy, New friendship, high adventure, and a crown,

  1. How is the way of life?
  2. How should be the journey of life?
  3. What did the poet seek as a boy?

Why had Prospero raised a violent storm in the sea?


Read the incident again and answer the following question.

What is the humour element in the above incident?


Identify the speaker/character.

‘ Remember the tiny penknife he gave me last year’.


Answer the following question based on the reading of the story. Do not forget to go back to the passage whenever necessary to find and confirm the answer.

Action Effect
While you warm yourself I will prepare the best tea.
I saved enough money  
  Six hundred and two villages were destroyed.
It was a terrible earthquake and it was felt  
I ran back to the village  
They lifted the door  
I went to thank the Army Officer  

How did Hamid’s friends show that they enjoyed eating the sweets?


We should develop the ability to learn from______

  1. self
  2. others
  3. books

Write down the word that alliterate in the poetic line below

Festival of Flowers.


Do you think this was a good idea?


He exercised with Louise every day.


What did Grandmother feel about trees growing in the house?


What did Raj buy?


Why did Muthu and his friends step out of the train?


What is the difference between this toy train and a normal train?


It ploughs soil before _________.


The second daughter ________ the milet to a flock of birds.


They ate a bowl of __________.


His father wanted him to do well in ______.


The old man put _____ on the mouth of the gourd.


The message was to gather on ______.


______always stays to the last in our needs.


Who made the tree become a monster?


Mostly piggy banks look like______.


One day Chris tried to draw a ______.


What did Nasruddin boast about?


The rabbit had


What did the boy wonder about?


How did the animals know that the king was just a jackal?


How can we identify insecure websites?


Being a bachelor, the stranger had no patience with children.


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×