English

How did Holmes' digressions sometimes prove in the end to have a bearing on the matter on hand? - English Elective - NCERT

Advertisements
Advertisements

Question

Examine the structure of the short story ‘Adventure of the Three Garridebs’ with the help of this framework

  • The narrator of the story
  • Introduction of the topic of the story
  • Introduction of the main characters in the plot
  • Development of the plot
  • Climax
  • Resolution of the mystery.
Answer in Brief
Advertisements

Solution

  • The introduction of the story: The story opens with a faint reflection of the climax. Watson, the narrator, does not give the climax entirely. However, he does tell the reader how the experience will be in the end.
  • Introduction of the topic of the story: The narrator does not hit the nail on the head, he rather lets the reader explore the story as the situation unfolds itself. However, Watson does not make the reader wait for too long.

  • Introduction of the main characters in the plot: Watson, the narrator takes the hold of the narration in the very beginning introducing the reader to the story. However, we get to know him only once he introduces the reader to him. And it is when Holmes addresses Watson, we come to know the name of the narrator. For it is a first-person narrative, we have to wait and move as the narrator describes all the events.

  • Development of the plot: In the beginning, Holmes is talking about a person with a particular surname and that there is a need to find a person with the surname. Then he tells Watson to wait for the person who has assigned the task to the detective as Holmes wants the person in question himself to explain the situation to his friend. Then arrives, John Garrideb of Kansas, who explains the reason for why is there a need of another surname. And it is made clear why Nathan approached Holmes for the task as it was John who approached Nathan for the same reason. And then further the story unfolds and with it is the truth explored.

  • Climax: The climax is built as the series of events are described. There are clues laid for the reader to guess, yet the narrator does not give away the resolution. The reader guesses the possibilities. Ultimately a stage comes where the story reaches its height when Holmes is sure of the identity of the suspect and is sure of evil intentions and yet his motives are not clear. It is all to be discovered by the reader as he/she advances to the final tragedy.

  • Resolution of the mystery: The resolution unleashes a comical tragedy. The reader is surprised and feels funny as well, thanks to the witty detective that leads the case. A faint reflection of the emotions that the reader might go in the ending was already given in the beginning, yet the resolution was unknown. It is not just the tragedy revealed but along with it is revealed the other side of the main character Sherlock Holmes and his friendship with Dr. Watson. There is more than the expected revealed. The digressions of Holmes are justified in the end as well. It was a mystery resolved in the end.

shaalaa.com
Writing Skills
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
Chapter 1.4: The Adventure of the Three Garridebs - Appreciation [Page 54]

APPEARS IN

NCERT English (Elective) - Woven Words
Chapter 1.4 The Adventure of the Three Garridebs
Appreciation | Q 1 | Page 54

RELATED QUESTIONS

Write a short tourist leaflet on a place of historical importance with the help of the following points: 
(i) How to reach there?
(ii) Where to Stay?
(iii) Historical importance of the place.
(iv) Shopping Attraction.
(v) Add your own points.

You had gone on a trekking expendition with a group of friends. As night closed in, you realised that you were separated from the group. Describe your initial feelings and the place where you got lost. How did you spend the night alone before you were reunited with your group? 


What could these persons have done?


There are two pauses when Kaspar tells Wilhelmine in the last stanza that it was a famous victory. Nay … nay…my little girl, quoth he.What do these pauses show?


What do you like about this poem?


Can the poem The Patriot be considered a dramatic monologue? Justify.


Show liow Narayan depicts women in the story and their role in a man’s life.


Write a short story that ends with the words “……………… I really doubt if things could have turned out any better.”


Anil is too fast a runner not to come first in the race. (Begin: Anil is so………….) 


Sergius tells Bluntschli in the play "you're not a man, you're a machine." Do you agree with Sergius' assessment of Blunts ii? Give your views.


What could the narrator hear as he was lying down?


The anthology `ISC Collection of Short Stories' includes several stories in which a woman is a central character. Which female character has awakened your admiration, sympathy or interest and why? 


This is the funniest movie I have ever seen.
(Begin : Never ………….)


Fill in each of the numbered blanks with the correct form of the word given in brackets. Do not copy the passage, but write in correct serial order the word or phrase appropriate to the blank space. 

Example:
(0) From his perch behind the clock, Hugo could (0)……. (see) everything.


We have had to respect for nature. Now we are suffering from the effects of global warming. 


Not many people read for pleasure these days.
(Begin: Few ................................. ) 


Write a short story beginning with this sentence:
When the last of the guests left, I went back into the hall.


Distinguish between the following pairs of sentences.

You will find the historian and the scientist in the archaeology and natural science sections of the museum respectively.


How did the narrator learn to distinguish between 'a flask' and 'a thermos'?


Give reasons for the following.

Satyajit’s recollection of the forgerer when he was on the train.


Go to your college library and collect and read the poems written by Sarojini Naidu.


Find out information about the Mahavastra of Maharashtra - Paithani.


Look at this cartoon by R.K. Laxman. Read the sentence given below the cartoon. Discuss the following questions with your partner.

  • What is it about?
  • Do you find it funny? If so, why?
  • Do you think a cartoon is a serious drawing? Why or why not?


The poet says, “Beauty is heard in …”
Can you hear beauty? Add a sound that you think is beautiful to the sounds the poet thinks are beautiful.
The poet, Keats, said:
Heard melodies are Sweet,
But those unheard are sweeter.
What do you think this means? Have you ever heard a song in your head, long after the song was sung or played?


What is beauty? Where can, in the poet’s opinion, beauty be seen, heard, and experienced?


Make a short list of things you find difficult to do. For example:

turning a somersault

threading a needle

Compare your list with the others in the class. Can you explain why you find these things difficult to do?


List the reactions of the agricultural officer to the author’s inquiry about Kasbai rice seeds. One is done for you.

(a) He had not heard of Kasbai.

(b) ___________________________

(c) ___________________________


The writer goes in search of an invaluable indigenous variety of seeds. List three reasons for the importance of keeping records of our indigenous agricultural practices.


Search in your college library or on the internet for at least five stories where a king or any great person has forgiven a losing king, culprit, or offender. There are many such stories that you might have read in your history books. One such story is of Alexander and Porus. Find at least five stories and write their summarised version in your notebook.


Multinational companies expect a different type of Professional CV. Browse through the net to gather information about it.


Identify the incorrect statements from the following and correct them.


You must have heard about the Film and Television Institute of India (FTII), Pune. It is India's top media Institute. It plays an important role in providing talent to commercial cinema, TV, and web serials. Browse the internet and find information about other institutes in India and abroad, write it in your notebook.


Discuss the following and write about the following in your own words in 5-6 lines.

What would you do, if something like this happens to you?


Think and write in your own words.

How can the tender maiden Autumn become a full-grown woman? What change in nature does this imply?


Discuss in groups the procedure of planting a tree. Write the steps in bullet points and present them before the class.

  • ______
  • ______
  • ______
  • ______

Imagine you are Dorothy and write about the day’s events in 5-8 lines in your (Dorothy’s) diary.


Write a report of the following event in about 100-120 words.

‘Educational Development Day’ was organized in your school on 15th July. The District Collector was the Chief Guest of the event. As part of the event, many competitions were held and the prizes were distributed to the winners and participants. It was a grand and successful event. Now, as the member of the organizing committee, write a report on the event in about 120 words.


How do you cook rice in your house?

Fill in the gaps in this recipe for cooking rice. Use the words in the box

boil

water

heat

keep

rice

lid

low

water

more

ready

What you'll need 

  • 1 cup uncooked white rice 
  • 2 cups water 
  • pinch of salt

How to make it

  1. ______the rice until the ______runs clear. 
  2. Drain the water and ______ aside.
  3. In a medium sized pan, bring water to ______. 
  4. Add the salt, stir, and then add the rinsed and drained ______.
  5. Reduce the heat, cover the rice, and let it simmer on ______ heat for 20 minutes.
  6. Check after 15 minutes to see if all the ______ has evaporated. If it has, the rice is ______.
  7. If not, replace the ______ and let the rice simmer for 5 ______
  8. Remove from ______ and serve

The word in the sentence is jumbled. Write them in order.

footprint to someone this belonged.


Now complete the following suitably.

________ the teacher walked into the room.


Use the option to fill in the blank.

The cows ______ grazing in the field.


How did the grandmother spend the last few hours of her life?


What did he keep doing while on his rounds?


What was her first impression of America?


Why did K.C’s words shock Sletherby?


Write conversation on the following situation.

Between two friends about planting trees


Write conversation on the following situation.

Between a father and a son on choice of a career


Suggest some ways by which we can maintain a calm temperament under all circumstances.


Why was Miss Meadows upset and dejected?


List six gadgets that you want to purchase. Write them according to your priorities and state the reasons.

S.No. Gadgets Reasons
     
     
     
     
     
     

Attempt a description of the following process, in about 100 word each, either using the imperative or the passive.

Obtaining a demand draft from a bank


Write a composition (300 - 350 words) on the following:

It is very important for young people to spend time quietly or alone for a short while every day. If you were given an hour to spend on your own, how will you spend it? What will you learn from the process?


Read the given sentence and underline the no word.

There is nothing to do.


Write a dialogue between a student and teacher on 'Importance of Yoga'.


When Luz Long said, 'something must be eating you' he meant that Jesse Owens must be ______.


"A Daniel come to judgement! Yea a Daniel" Who is being described in these words? By whom?


Write an original short story that begins with the following words:

My mother stopped suddenly at the doorway and stared in amazement at ..........


With reference to the short story Quality, trace the journey of the Gessler Brothers from “ld is an Ardt!" to the bitter realization of “Dey dake it away from us, who lofe our boods….bresently i haf no work.” Write your answer in about 200-250 words.


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×