English

Briefly explain the following statement from the text. “You have passed through a fantastic experience: or more correctly, a catastrophic experience.” - English Core

Advertisements
Advertisements

Question

Briefly explain the following statement from the text.

You have passed through a fantastic experience: or more correctly, a catastrophic experience.”

Answer in Brief
Advertisements

Solution

This statement was made by Rajendra to Prof. Gaitonde in the text The Adventure by Jayant Vishnu Narlikar. Rajendra made this statement in the context of Prof. Gaitonde experiencing a different version of the outcome of the Battle of Panipat. Prof Gaitonde was a historian and he was invited to a seminar to speak on the Battle of Panipat. He was to make a point that if in the battle of Panipat the Marathas emerged victorious then what would have happened. Interestingly, Prof. Gaitonde happened to experience the very hypothesis as reality. He entered a different level of consciousness and was witnessing events like the Battle of Panipat in an altogether different version. In the History books, the Marathas are mentioned as being a loser in the battle but in his experience, the Marathas emerged victoriously. Prof. Gaitonde was unable to understand this phenomenon. It is in this context, Rajendra tried to offer a scientific explanation to rationalise Prof. Gaitonde's experience. He meant to say that what Prof. Gaitonde experienced was not imaginative or fantastic but was also real. He tried to explain this in light of the catastrophic theory. According to this theory, there can be many alternative realities simultaneously existing. An observer sees only one of the alternatives. By applying this theory, Rajendra tried to explain the outcome of the Battle of Panipat as revealed to Prof. Gaitonde. The catastrophic theory has been developed by observing the outcome of experiments on small systems like atom and their constituent particles. The behaviour of these systems cannot be predicted definitely even if all the physical laws governing those systems are known.

shaalaa.com
Reading Skills
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
Chapter 7: The Adventure - Understanding the text [Page 69]

APPEARS IN

NCERT English (Core) - Hornbill
Chapter 7 The Adventure
Understanding the text | Q 2 | Page 69

RELATED QUESTIONS

Read the following extract and then do all the activities that follow :

I rain into a stranger as he passed by
“Oh, excuse me please” was my reply.
He said, “please excuse me too; wasn't even watching for you.”
We were very polite, this stranger and I.
We went on out way and we said good-bye.
But at home a different story is told.
How we treat out loved ones, young and old.
Later that day, cooking the evening meal,
My daughter stood beside me very still.
When I turned, I nearly knoked her down.
“Move out of the way,” I said with a frown.
She walked away, her little heart broken.
I didn't realize how harshly I'd spoken.
While I lay awake in bed,
God's still small voice came to me and said,
“While Dealing with a stranger, common courtesy you use,
But children you love, you seem to abuse.”

A1. Order- 
The incidents narrated in the extract are arranged in a jumbled manner here, Rearrange them in a proper order as they occur in the extract:
(i) The poet and the stranger went on their way saying good-bye.
(ii) Seeking excuse politely from the stranger, she went her way.
(iii) The poet ran into a stranger on the road.
(iv) The poet yelled at her daughter.

A2. Poetic device:
Make a list of rhyming pairs from the second stanza and note down the rhyme scheme of the same stanza.

A3. Personal Response:
Understanding and politeness are the essentials of out everyday life. Explain your views in brief.

A4. Creativity -
Frame two poetic lines on the following situation using a rhyming pattern with the help of clues given:
“While introducing great personalities, we praise them highly and talk about their qualities, but while speaking
about our friends we may not follow the same trend.”
While introducing great personalities, — a
------------------------------------ — a
But while speaking about our friends, — b
------------------------------------ — b


We know that chimps are intelligent because 


What does the phrase 'as if he were on needles' mean? Can you think of another phrase with a similar meaning substituting the word 'needless'?


Both Ramanand and Azam Khan seem to have very fixed views. How does Ramanand score over Azam Khan towards the end of the story?


“I have done something; oh, God! I've done something real at last.” Why does Andrew say this? What does it mean?


How, according to you, can peace and liberty be maintained in a state?


Why is the quality of pity earth-bound while the other two passions are elevating?


Comment on the lines that make you visualise the colourful image of the peacock.


Find from the story one word for the following.

a very narrow passage between buildings ______


Pick out words from the poem to fill in the web diagram. They should be related to the theme in the web.


Read the poem and write 3 qualities of the following. 


Kite - flying in Gujarat, is a competitive sport - cum - festival.


For preparing questions based on the poem, an overall understanding of the poem is a must. Discuss with your partner and prepare a set of five questions.

For example:

  1. What is the name of the bridge?
  2. ________________________________
  3. ________________________________
  4. ________________________________
  5. ________________________________
  6. ________________________________

Discuss in groups and share with one another.

How your family relaxes on weekends.


Where do we find all types of wild animals in urban areas?


Given below are various professions in column A and in column B, the nature of work in respective professions. Match the columns.

A B
(i) Anaesthetist (a) Specialist in the treatment of problems concerning the position of teeth and jaws.
(ii) Pharmacist (b) A person who designs buildings and supervises the process of constructing them.
(iii) Orthodentist (c) A person who is in charge of a newspaper or of a part of a newspaper.
(iv) Dermitologist (d) The medical study of the skin and its diseases.
(v) Architect (e) A person who has been trained to prepare medicines and sell them to the public.
(vi) Chartered Accountant (f) A person whose job is to give drugs which makes the person not feel pain especially in preparation for a medical operation.
(vii) Editor (g) A person who is engaged in the profession of accounting and examining the statements and records of accounts.

Fill in the gap, choosing a word from the bracket to make an appropriate comparison.

(tall / quiet / humble / merry / busy / slippery / fast / sly / slow / big)

as ______ as a lark


Visit a library: Find the stories of 

  • Mulla Nasiruddin 
  • Gopal Bhand and 
  • Tenali Raman. Share them in the class.

Suggest what you would do in the following situation:

You realise that you no longer want to pursue your studies in the stream you have selected.


Find out the different processes by which fabrics are made. Find illustrations and write a few lines on each process.


Select the correct options :

A Midsummer-Night’s Dream is a ___________________.

  1. poetic drama
  2. comedy of errors
  3. a comedy based on fantasy
  4. a character play
  5. a revenge tragedy
  6. belongs to realm of dreams

Shakespeare’s poetry has come to be valued for its own sake on the stage. Comment with reference to the play ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream.’


Discuss and write 1-2 lines about the following,

Why Bushi told Yonamine not to travel at night.


Read the following sentence aloud. Write who said it and to whom.

“Would you lend me this, just this?”


Pick out words from the poem that describe the following. List them in Column ‘A’. Substitute each of those describing words with another word/phrase of the same meaning.

  A (Poetic words) B (Your own words)
the ‘Autumn’ a maiden fair  
stars    
moonlight    
cooing of birds    

Find one example of the following given below from the poem: Simile.


We find the following in the script of a skit or play. Rearrange these steps in the proper order and write them down in the form of a flow chart.


Prepare a ‘PowerPoint’ presentation, using one slide for each of the above points. Present your review in a PPT format in the classroom.


Read ‘The Story of the Amulet’ by E. Nesbit.


The poet uses a free, conversational style in his poem. It is also called Colloquial style.

Pick out and write down such lines or expressions that support the above statement.

  1. ______ you have not done what I asked.
  2. _______________________.
  3. _______________________.
  4. _______________________.
  5. _______________________.
  6. _______________________.

Write what the following do, with the help of the poem.

ripples


What happened to the young seagull when it landed on the green sea?


__________________was the chief of all spirits


Give two reasons why Miranda was so concerned about Ferdinand.


The author was going to New York.


Read the following line from the poem and answer the question given below.

Let us learn to walk with a smile and a song,
No matter if things do sometimes go wrong;

  1. What does the poet expect everyone to learn?
  2. What should we do when things go wrong sometimes?

Pick out the words which rhyme with the given words and write similar rhyming words on your own.

1. far    
2. fear    
3. low    
4. kind    
5. remain    
6. they    

When are we in a state of trance?


Read the lines and answer the questions.

And in fighting for their country, faith and king
noble impressions on people’s minds would ring

  1. What does ‘noble impression’ mean?
  2. Who can leave a noble impression?

Identify the speaker/character.

Don't worry, Madam, it's only a warning.


When the author returned from England to Dehradun, he found Grandfather's dream had come true because the______.


Read the story on your own. Discuss in a group and complete the story map below.

A story map is the main events of the story given in a flow chart.


What is as sharp as a blade?


Identify the sports and the sports personalities from the lesson and fill in the table.

Sports Name of the player & Field of sports Awards
   
   
   

Why did the girls snigger?


Is the brother boastful? What makes you think so?


Where is the poet going in the dream?


They rode back home quickly.


He got _________ the disease.


Choose the odd one out.


Look at the picture and tick Choose the correct word.


Answer using Yes or No and pick sentence from the story to support your answer.

Did Robinson’s ship sink?


Who is the hero of this story?


What happened to Jayan?


Leaf cutter ants drink ______.


Write the word with same meaning.

queue- ______


What is the one thing you will try and improve after reading the story? How?


The fir tree was sad ______.


The garden Alice saw was


What did the boy make with the branches of the tree?


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×