English

What Were Watson'S Observations on the Stick Left Behind by Dr. Mortimer? How Far Did Sherlock Holmes Prove Him Wrong? - English Core

Advertisements
Advertisements

Question

What were Watson's observations on the stick left behind by Dr. Mortimer? How far did Sherlock Holmes prove him wrong? (in about 125 words)

Advertisements

Solution

Watson likens the stick left behind by Dr. Mortimer to what ‘the old-fashioned family practitioner used to carry’. He observes the worn out condition of the stick and concludes that the man must be a ‘successful, elderly medical man’ who practises in the countryside and travels a lot on foot. The silver band also displays the words ‘from his friends of the C.C.H.’ and the year ‘1884’. Watson infers that the stick must have been a presentation from a local hunt.
 

Holmes, however, after examining the stick himself, declares most of his friend’s conclusion to be ‘erroneous’. He points out that the stick must have been presented to the doctor by a hospital and C.C.H. would then mean ‘Charing Cross Hospital’. He further reasons that Dr Mortimer must have practised in town before shifting his practice to the country five years back; that he is a young man under thirty; that he is ‘amiable’, ‘unambitious’ and ‘absent-minded’; and that he possesses a dog, whose teeth marks are visible on the stick.

shaalaa.com
Reading Skills
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
2013-2014 (March) All India Set 1

RELATED QUESTIONS

Read the passage carefully.

1. I remember my childhood as being generally happy and can recall experiencing some of the most carefree times of my life. But I can also remember, even more vividly, moments of being deeply frightened. As a child, I was truly terrified of the dark and getting lost. These fears were very real and caused me some extremely uncomfortable moments.

2. Maybe it was the strange way things looked and sounded in my familiar room at night that scared me so much. There was never total darkness, but a street light or passing car lights made clothes hung over a chair take on the shape of an unknown beast. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw curtains move when there was no breeze. A tiny creak in the floor would sound a hundred times louder than in the daylight and my imagination would take over, creating burglars and monsters. Darkness always made me feel helpless. My heart would pound and I would lie very still so that 'the enemy' wouldn't discover me.

3. Another childhood fear of mine was that I would get lost, especially on the way home from school. Every morning, I got on the school bus right near my home ‒ that was no problem. After school, though, when all the buses were lined up along the curve, I was terrified that I would get on the wrong one and be taken to some unfamiliar neighbourhood. I would scan the bus for the faces of my friends, make sure that the bus driver was the same one that had been there in the morning, and even then ask the others over and over again to be sure I was in the right bus. On school or family trips to an amusement park or a museum, I wouldn't  let the leaders out of my sight. And of course, I was never very adventurous when it came to taking walks or hikes because I would go only where I was sure I would never get lost.

4. Perhaps, one of the worst fears I had as a child was that of not being liked or accepted by others. First of all, I was quite shy. Secondly, I worried constantly about my looks, thinking people wouldn't like me because I was too fat or wore braces. I tried to wear 'the right clothes' and had intense arguments with my mother over the importance of wearing flats instead of saddled shoes to school. Being popular was very important to me then and the fear of not being liked was a powerful one.

5. One of the processes of evolving from a child to an adult is  being able to recognise and overcome our fears. I have learnt that darkness does not have to take on a life of its own, that others can help me when I am lost and that friendliness and sincerity will encourage people to like me. Understanding the things that scared us as children helps to cope with our lives as adults.

(a) On the basis of your reading of the above passage, make notes using headings and subheadings. Use recognizable abbreviations wherever necessary.

(b) Make a summary of the passage in not more than 80 words using the notes made and also suggest a suitable title.


How is the father’s helplessness brought out in the poem?


How do Shahid and the writer react to the knowledge that Shahid is going to die?


What is the central argument of the speaker?


The poem is a satire against the present political class. How effectively does it convey the anger and anguish of the common man trapped in the system?


Discuss the activities carried out by a farmer.


Read the story and choose the appropriate meaning.

Masterpiece ____________.


Read the description of the Kabaddi match and do the following:

Describe, in your own words, the important events in the first half.


Form groups and discuss the following question:

The events described in the poem take place at a certain place, at a certain period of the year, under specific weather conditions. Describe the place, the time, and the weather conditions.


Read the passage and find the verbs used with the following nouns and phrases:

  • volcano 
  • molten rock
  • volcanic mountain
  • dust
  • 165 village and towns
  • the wind and the sea
  • seeds
  • bird

Complete the following sentence using your idea:

I can ______.


Write a short note on the following:

Prince Siddharth’s protected life.


Use the following expressions in your own sentences:

  1. We all agree that
  2. It is he/she who
  3. Don’t you see
  4. None of us

What changes do we see in the life of human beings when the season changes? Write with reference to their clothes.


Answer in your own words.

What excuses did Neel give to avoid cleaning his room?


The poet uses a free, conversational style in his poem. It is also called Colloquial style.

Pick out and write down such lines or expressions that support the above statement.

  1. ______ you have not done what I asked.
  2. _______________________.
  3. _______________________.
  4. _______________________.
  5. _______________________.
  6. _______________________.

Read the following. 

  • Skipper: captain of a ship or boat.
  • Dipper: This word has two meanings. Dipper means a container for taking out water. Also, there are two constellations called Little Dipper (Little Bear) and Big Dipper (Big Bear) in the sky.
  • Milky Way: The band of light consisting of stars that spreads across the sky at night. 

What made the reporter gaze at the author?


Why did Shepherd-Barron reduce the PIN number from six digits to four?


Why was it a struggle for the children to dry their clothes?


Why does the writer think that the peepul tree is a great show off?


What does the peepul do?


Gulliver managed to reach the land as he was______.


The old man was carrying _____.


______are the real wealth.


The villagers took oath not to harm the _______.


Ani grew the seeds well.


Draw me some hair, quickly, I look like a ______.


Write the correct word.

rooster, king, hen, tiger, queen, tigress.


How does Tagore acknowledge Gandhi’s noble work?


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×