English
Karnataka Board PUCPUC Science Class 11

Show that the Two-body Decay of this Type Must Necessarily Give an Electron of Fixed Energy And, Therefore, Cannot Account for the Observed Continuous Energy Distribution in the β-decay of a Neutron Or a Nucleus

Advertisements
Advertisements

Question

Consider the decay of a free neutron at rest : n → p + e

Show that the two-body decay of this type must necessarily give an electron of fixed energy and, therefore, cannot account for the observed continuous energy distribution in the β-decay of a neutron or a nucleus

 

Advertisements

Solution 1

The decay process of free neutron at rest is given as:
→ p + e
From Einstein’s mass-energy relation, we have the energy of electron as Δmc2

Where,

Δm = Mass defect = Mass of neutron – (Mass of proton + Mass of electron)

c = Speed of light

Δm and c are constants. Hence, the given two-body decay is unable to explain the continuous energy distribution in the β-decay of a neutron or a nucleus. The presence of neutrino νon the LHS of the decay correctly explains the continuous energy distribution.

shaalaa.com

Solution 2

Let the masses of the electron and proton be m and M respectively. Let v and V be the velocities of electron and proton respectively. Using law of conservation of momentum. Momentum of electron + momentum of proton = momentum of neutron

`:. mv + MV = 0 => V = - m/M v`

Clearly the electron and the proton move in opposite directions. If mass `trianglem` has been conveted into energy in the reaction then

`1/2mv^2 + 1/2 MV^2 =  trianglem xx c^2`

or `1/2mv^2 + 1/2M[-m/M]^2v^2 = trianglemc^2`

or `1/2mv^2[1+m/M] = trianglemc^2`

or `v^2 = (2Mtrianglemc^2)/(m(M+m))`

Thus, it is proved that the value of v2 is fixed since all the quantities in right hand side are constant. It establishes that the emitted electron must have a fixed energy and thus we cannot account for the continuous energy distribution in the β-decay of a neutron.

shaalaa.com
  Is there an error in this question or solution?

RELATED QUESTIONS

The rate of change of total momentum of a many-particle system is proportional to the ______ on the system.


Answer carefully, with reason:

Is the total linear momentum conserved during the short time of an elastic collision of two balls?


Two identical ball bearings in contact with each other and resting on a frictionless table are hit head-on by another ball bearing of the same mass moving initially with a speed V. If the collision is elastic, which of the following figure is a possible result after collision?


A trolley of mass 200 kg moves with a uniform speed of 36 km/h on a frictionless track. A child of mass 20 kg runs on the trolley from one end to the other (10 m away) with a speed of 4 m s–1 relative to the trolley in a direction opposite to the its motion, and jumps out of the trolley. What is the final speed of the trolley? How much has the trolley moved from the time the child begins to run?


Solve the following problem.

A spring ball of mass 0.5 kg is dropped from some height. On falling freely for 10 s, it explodes into two fragments of mass ratio 1:2. The lighter fragment continues to travel downwards with a speed of 60 m/s. Calculate the kinetic energy supplied during the explosion.


What is inelastic collision? In which way it is different from an elastic collision. Mention a few examples in day-to-day life for inelastic collision.


A ball is thrown vertically down from height of 80 m from the ground with an initial velocity 'v'. The ball hits the ground, loses `1/6`th of its total mechanical energy, and rebounds back to the same height. If the acceleration due to gravity is 10 ms-2, the value of 'v' is


A ball moving with velocity 5 m/s collides head on with another stationary ball of double mass. If the coefficient of restitution is 0.8, then their velocities (in m/s) after collision will be ____________.


In inelastic collision, ____________.


A cricket ball of mass 150 g moving with a speed of 126 km/h hits at the middle of the bat, held firmly at its position by the batsman. The ball moves straight back to the bowler after hitting the bat. Assuming that collision between ball and bat is completely elastic and the two remain in contact for 0.001s, the force that the batsman had to apply to hold the bat firmly at its place would be ______.


A ball of mass m, moving with a speed 2v0, collides inelastically (e > 0) with an identical ball at rest. Show that for a general collision, the angle between the two velocities of scattered balls is less than 90°.


The bob A of a pendulum released from horizontal to the vertical hits another bob B of the same mass at rest on a table as shown in figure.


If the length of the pendulum is 1 m, calculate

  1. the height to which bob A will rise after collision.
  2. the speed with which bob B starts moving. Neglect the size of the bobs and assume the collision to be elastic.

Two pendulums with identical bobs and lengths are suspended from a common support such that in rest position the two bobs are in contact (Figure). One of the bobs is released after being displaced by 10° so that it collides elastically head-on with the other bob.

  1. Describe the motion of two bobs.
  2. Draw a graph showing variation in energy of either pendulum with time, for 0 ≤ t ≤ 2T, where T is the period of each pendulum.

A drunkard walking in a narrow lane takes 5 steps forward and 3 steps backward, followed again by 5 steps forward and 3 steps backward, and so on. Each step is 1 m long and required 1 s to cover. How long the drunkard takes to fall in a pit 13 m away from the start?


An alpha-particle of mass m suffers 1-dimensional elastic collision with a nucleus at rest of unknown mass. It is scattered directly backwards losing, 64% of its initial kinetic energy. The mass of the nucleus is ______.


What do the objects do "after collision"?


What is a collision?


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×