Question

The following question has two statements P and Q. They may look factually absurd. You have to ignore this absurdly and concentrate only upon the logic involved in its statement.
Mark the answer as
 P: All fish can fly. Some fish are birds. All birds are naughty. Therefore some naughty can fly.
Q: Some fish are birds. All birds are naughty. Therefore all fish are naughty.

Options

• if both P and Q are true. 

• if both P and Q are false or doubtful. 

• if P is true and Q is false or doubtful. 

• if P is false or doubtful and Q is true. 

Answer 1

if P is true and Q is false or doubtful.