English

Overview of Forms of Government: Totalitarian and Authoritarian States, and Liberal Democratic State

Advertisements

Topics

CISCE: Class 12

Definition: Totalitarian States

  • "Totalitarian state is the veritable contradictory of the Liberal Democratic type of government. The scope and authority of government is not limited, but just the reverse is total." - Finer
  • "In current political literature, the term 'Totalitarian State' is used in contrast with the term "Liberal Democratic State." - Asirvatham 
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Nature of a Totalitarian State

  • Against Rule of Law
  • Complete Centralisation of Power
  • One-Party System
  • Control over Individuals and Society
  • Based on Force and Coercion 
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Major Features of a Totalitarian State

  • Totally opposed to a Liberal Democratic State. 
  • The ruler’s ideology becomes the state ideology, compulsory for all citizens. 
  • People have no real role in decision-making 
  • Force and fear are the basis of state authority and obedience. 
  • Rights exist only at the will of the ruler and for the power of the state.
  • Belief in a monolithic society-one leader, one party, one ideology, one rule.
  • Press and mass media are controlled by the state.
  • Nation and state power are glorified above everything else.
  • Opposed to social, economic, and political pluralism. 
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Fundamental Features of a Modern Totalitarian State

  • Total Political Control.
  • One Dominant Party System.
  • Elaborate State Ideology.
  • Control over the Judiciary and Media.
  • Mass Mobilisation and Forced Participation.
CISCE: Class 12

Definition: Authoritarian State

  • Authoritarian state as one in which "all authority and power are concentrated in the hands of a few i.e., the government whose rule is essentially not responsible. The people participate in few of their decisions but are subject to all of them." - C.H. Dillon
  • "An Authoritarian government is characterised by the possession of supreme authority either by one person or by a minority group which is in no way accountable to the people over whom control is exercised." - E.B. Schulz 
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Features of Authoritarian State

  • Limited Political Competition
  • Absence of a Dominant Ideology
  • Restricted Scope of Politics
  • Use of Force and Coercion
  • Low Priority to Civil Liberties
  • Elite-Based Rule
  • Concentration of Power 
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Chief Features of an Authoritarian State

  • A state ruled by an autocratic government.
  • The executive is the most powerful organ, and it dominates the legislature.
  • Lack of Judicial Independence.
  • Limited Political Pluralism.
  • Restriction of Rights and Freedoms.
  • Fear, force, coercion and political repression is used to secure compliance.
  • Controlled Civil Society.
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Forms of Authoritarian States> raditional Authoritarian State

  • Ruled by a small ruling group, powerful aristocratic family, elite family, or a small class.
  • Political power is monopolised by a few individuals.
  • Maintained through traditions, customs, religion, and personal loyalties.
  • Instruments of rule include force, coercion, wealth, corruption, and family or group loyalties.
  • Examples include rule by Amirs, Kings, feudal lords, or elite families. 
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Forms of Authoritarian States> Modern Authoritarian State

  • Ruled by a coalition of military officers, bureaucrats, technocrats, or elite groups.
  • Power is often seized by a military dictator, military junta, or civil junta.
  • Regime promotes the ideology of modernization and development.
  • Propaganda and control of mass media.
  • Facade constitution or controlled political system.
CISCE: Class 12

Definition: Dictatorship

"Dictatorship is a government of one man who has not obtained his position by inheritance but by either force or consent (manipulated consent), or a combination of both. Dictatorship means coming into power by force and then securing popular consent through manipulated elections or coming to power through legal means but establishing an autocratic/authoritarian rule by trampling the opponents and establishing a personal autocratic rule." - Alfred Cobban 

CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Concept of Dictatorship

  • Dictatorship is a form of government in which one ruler exercises unlimited or excessive authority.
  • It is also known as autocracy or authoritarian government.
  • The dictator rules according to his own will and is answerable only to himself, not to the people.
  • Dictatorial rule is maintained through force, fear, coercion, repression, and manipulation.
  • The dictator controls the media, the judiciary, and the political institutions to retain power.
  • There is suppression of opposition and no genuine political competition.
  • Examples of dictators include Hitler, Mussolini, Franco, Salazar, Idi Amin, and Ayub Khan, Zia-ul-Haq, and Pervez Musharraf.
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Basic Features Of Dictatorship

  • Rule of one person or a small group led by one person.
  • Dictatorship comes into existence by force.
  • Irresponsible Rule.
  • Backed by Military Power of the State.
  • The ruler acts for the whole nation.
  • Rule based on Force and Violence.
  • Totally opposed to Democracy.
  • Little Importance to People's Rights and Freedoms.
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Critical Evaluation of Dictatorship

  • Little intrinsic merit.
  • Dictatorship enables strong and prompt decision-making.
  • Decisions face no institutional opposition.
  • Complete centralisation of authority.
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Main Points of Criticism against Dictatorship

  • Formation of Government rests upon Force and Violence.
  • Unreal and Manipulated Elections.
  • The executive is excessively powerful.
  • Rule of a Person and not of Law.
  • Centralised Authority System.
  • Lack of Independence of the Judiciary.
  • Use of Propaganda. 
CISCE: Class 12

Difference Between Totalitarian and Authoritarian States

Basis of Difference Totalitarian States Authoritarian States
Political Pluralism No political pluralism Limited and controlled pluralism
Legitimacy Forced legitimacy Engineered or manipulated legitimacy
State–Society Relation No separation between state and society Limited separation between state and society
Ideology One official state ideology Use of ideology to justify rule
Party System Single party and single leader dominate The party system used to support the dictator
Power Structure Complete centralisation of all powers Strong and dominant executive
Political Participation Forced and controlled participation Limited and regulated participation
Rule Rule of single-party leadership Rule of a dictator, not the rule of law
CISCE: Class 12

Definition: Liberal Democratic State

"A Liberal Democratic State is one in which people's power is supreme." 

CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Nature of Liberal Democratic State

  • Representative Government Formed by Duly and Freely Elected Representatives of the People.
  • Full Respect for all Civil Right and Liberties of the People.
  • Defined and Specified Power and Role of the Executive.
  • Limited Government.
  • System of Social, EconomicPolitical and Legal Checks and Balances.
  • Free and Open struggle for power in Society and Polity.
  • Freedom of the People to Form and Manage Political Parties and Associations. 
CISCE: Class 12

Key Points: Merits of Liberal Democracy

  • Representative and Responsible Government.
  • Better protection of interests of common man.
  • People's full Participation in Political Process.
  • Free and Open Struggle for Political Power.
  • Political Education for the people.
  • Government Based on Public Consent.
  • Peaceful and Orderly Change of Government.
  • Little Fear of Revolution.
  • Accountability of Government.
  • Active Civil Society. 
Advertisements
Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×