English
Tamil Nadu Board of Secondary EducationSSLC (English Medium) Class 9

Why do you think the poet describes the act of cutting a tree? What effect does it have on you as a reader?

Advertisements
Advertisements

Question

Why do you think the poet describes the act of cutting a tree? What effect does it have on you as a reader?

Long Answer
Advertisements

Solution 1

The killing of a tree – a cruel act – tree intends to live-even plants expand its species-man is a killer-very unkind towards trees-too selfish-destroys nature – a murder eventually-similar to killing a man-tree dies with its root cut-man dies with his heart attack.

shaalaa.com

Solution 2

The poet is a physician. He considers the act of killing of a tree as an evil act. He is of the view that it is nothing but murder. The woodcutter tries to cut down the tree. He cuts the trunk of the tree. Even after felling the tree, it can sprout from the bottom-most part of the trunk. Thus the effort is to be made to uproot it. Unless the anchored root is cut off and removed from the earth, killing is not complete.

The root is brought out to dry it in the sun and the air. The poet compares it to the killing of a man. The root is compared to the heart of a man. Every life is finished when the heart stops functioning. As the heart circulates the blood in the body, the root does the work of supplying water to every part of the tree. The reader is getting an awareness that he or

she should not indulge in the evil or cruel act of killing a tree that can live for a long time. It gives the realization that the killing of a tree and a man are one and the same. So every reader will stand against this cruelty and join hands for planting and growing trees.

shaalaa.com

Solution 3

The killing of a tree is a cruel act. The poet has made us realize that the felling of a tree is killing it. The word “Killing” is very effectively and earnestly used in this poem. Being a physician, the poet has dealt with the life and death of the tree. A man dies when the heart is affected. Similarly, a tree becomes lifeless only when its root is removed from the earth. The root of a tree is compared to the heart of a man.

The poem teaches a lesson to the readers that we must not be cruel towards any living thing, either a tree or man. Killing a tree is synonymous with murdering a man. Thus it is clear that the poet wants the readers to be kind to mankind. As readers, we must feel the pain inflicted on others by every one of our cruel acts through our word and deed.
“Let us not fell the trees before they fall”

shaalaa.com
Poetry (Class 9th)
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
Chapter 3.2: On Killing a Tree - Exercise [Page 77]

APPEARS IN

Samacheer Kalvi English Class 9 TN Board
Chapter 3.2 On Killing a Tree
Exercise | Q E. 3. | Page 77

RELATED QUESTIONS

And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep

Explain miles to go before I sleep.


Complete the summary of the poem by filling in the blanks.

After a long travel the poet entered a___________. He wondered to whom the wood _______! He realized that the owner of the wood lived in a ________. He thought that the owner would not be able to ___________him stopping in his woods to watch _____________ fill the woods. The poet felt that the horse would think it very _________ to stop near the woods as he had never _____. He was actually standing between the woods and _______. The time was ________. The horse indicated that the poet has made a ________ by shaking its head. The poet felt that the woods are lovely, _______ and ______. He suddenly realized that he had worldly ______which would not allow him to _______ in the woods for a long time.


What information does the poet highlight about the season and the time of the day in the poem?


In the morning glad I see
My foe outstretched beneath the tree

Who is the ‘foe’ referred to here?


How long does it take a tree to grow to its full size?


It takes much time to kill a tree,
Not a simple jab of the knife Will do it.

Why does it take much time to kill a tree?


What are the life sources needed for a tree to grow?


"Sweet creature!” said the Spider, “you're witty and you’re wise,
How handsome are your gauzy wings, how brilliant are your eyes!"

List the words used by the spider to describe the fly.


Tending onward to the ocean,
Just like mortal prime,

Where is the river flowing to?


And the finest of conventions ever held beneath the sun
Are the little family gatherings when the busy day is done.

When do they have their family gatherings?


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×