हिंदी

Despite being a half monster and half human, Caliban comes across as superior to Stephano and Trinculo. Justify the statement with supporting evidence from the Acts studied in 200-250 words. - English Literature

Advertisements
Advertisements

प्रश्न

Despite being a half monster and half human, Caliban comes across as superior to Stephano and Trinculo. Justify the statement with supporting evidence from the Acts studied in 200-250 words.

दीर्घउत्तर
Advertisements

उत्तर

In "The Tempest," Caliban, despite his supposed monster nature, frequently displays features that suggest he is more analytical and observant than Stephano and Trinculo, who are purportedly 'civilised' men. This disparity is prominently reflected in their interactions and plans on the island.

First and foremost, Caliban understands the island better than Stephano and Trinculo. He possesses an intuitive understanding of the island's natural resources and geography, which he uses to navigate and survive. For example, in Act II, Scene II, he appropriately explains the island's characteristics and resources to Stephano, offering to show him "the best springs" and promising to take him to "clustering filberts." This practical understanding demonstrates his adaptability and survival instincts, which Stephano and Trinculo lack as they navigate their surroundings.

Furthermore, Caliban's attempt to overthrow Prospero exhibits a level of sophistication and strategic thinking that Stephano and Trinculo lack. Caliban persuades Stephano to assassinate Prospero in Act III, Scene II, presenting a thorough plot to catch him sleeping and grab his magical books. Caliban is the mastermind here, demonstrating his ability to influence and lead action to achieve his intended outcome, as opposed to Stephano and Trinculo's intoxicated folly and lack of foresight.

Furthermore, Caliban's knowledge of his own captivity and longing for liberation demonstrate a depth of character and grasp of his surroundings that Stephano and Trinculo lack. He sees Prospero's power as oppressive and desires release, expressing deep feelings about his situation in various monologues that reflect on his sense of self and individuality.

Caliban's superior knowledge of the island, strategic scheming, and reflective comprehension of his own predicament all point to a higher level of character depth and competence than Stephano and Trinculo's more superficial, self-serving, and buffoonish behaviour. These parts of his character call into question traditional notions of 'monstrosity' and 'humanity', presenting him as a shockingly superior figure in many ways.

shaalaa.com
Writing Skills
  क्या इस प्रश्न या उत्तर में कोई त्रुटि है?
2023-2024 (March) Official

APPEARS IN

संबंधित प्रश्न

Your school is hosting an Inter-School Quiz Competition. 

Write out a notice to be displayed in your school, giving all the details about the event. 


In order to be successful, one should rely on oneself and not expect others to help. Express your view on the given statement. 


How has Dahl used personification in his poem?


The free bird thinks of another breeze
And the trade winds soft through
The sighing trees
And the fat worms waiting on a dawn-bright
Lawn and he names the sky his own.

Read the above lines and answer the question that follow.

What is meant by “free bird thinks of another breeze”?


There's nobody on the house-tops now...
Just a palsied few at the windows set;
For the best of the sight is, all allow,
At the Shambles' Gate-or, better yet,
By the very scaffold's foot, I trow.

Read the above lines and answer the question that follow.

Why does Browning say that the palsied watched the execution?


Don John: Come, let us to the banquet
                  [Exeunt all but Claudio] 

Claudio: Thus answer 1 in name of Benedick,
But hear this ill news with the ears of Claudio. 'Tis certain so; the prince woos for himself. Friendship is constant in all other things Save in the office and affairs of love. Therefore all hearts in love use their own tongues. Let every eye negotiate for itself, And trust no agent; for beauty is a witch Against whose charms faith melteth into blood. This is an accident of hourly proof, Which I Mistrusted not. Farewell, therefore, Hero.
[Enter Benedick] 

Benedick: Count Claudio?

Claudio: Yea, the same. 

(i) Where are the speakers? Describe Claudio's state of mind?
(ii) What has Don John just revealed to Claudio? 
(iii) Explain the lines:

"Therefore all hearts in love use their own tongues.
Let every eye negotiate for itself,
And trust no agent;"
(iv) How does Don John succeed in conveying his thoughts to Claudio? What is his intention in doing so? 
(v) Why is 'beauty' said to be a 'witch'? Which aspect of Claudio is seen here? 
(vi) Give the meanings of the following words as they are used in the context of the passage: ill; save; office; 


Last night’s dinner was cooked for us by father.
(Begin : Father …………… )


In the poem Breaking Out. the poet shows the gradual transformation of a young girl into a confident and independent individual who breaks the conventional stereotypes of society. Discuss with close reference to the text. 


Every one of them was an experienced mountaineer.

(Begin: There was no .................................) 


Given below is an interesting combination of words. Explain why they have been used together.

eternal brilliance


Distinguish between the following pairs of sentences.

The team played the two matches successfully.


Discuss with your partner and choose the correct alternative.

‘Government of the people, by the people and for the people, shall not perish from the earth’. This famous statement is made by - ______________________.


Discuss with your partner and choose the correct alternative.

A democratic country is governed by, its - __________________.


Imagine that you are the fellow pilgrim and you wish to share your experience of the incident in the poem.
Write a short article about it for a magazine/journal. Also, convey what change it has brought in your life.


Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar has cited the quotes by John Stuart Mill and Daniel O’Connel. Go through the lesson and write down 4 to 5 lines for each of them.


You have noticed that many of your classmates are not interested in outdoor games or participating in co-curricular activities. Discuss some ways in which they will be encouraged to participate in activities.


Describe the climax scene in your own words. Write your comments on it.


Write what you think about the following thoughts and actions of Mathilde :

Mathilde did not tell her friend about the loss and replacement.


Think and write in your own words.

Why does the traveller doubt that he shall ever come back?


Maintain a diary at least for a week. Write about your interactions with other people in your surroundings in 3-4 lines. Also write whether you find the interactions happy unhappy, satisfactory-unsatisfactory, enjoyable-stressful, etc.


Say ‘WHY’?

One should avoid getting angry about a difference of opinion.


Narrate an incident when you have experienced happiness, excitement, surprise. You can use the following clues.

With whom...
When did it happen...
Why...
Where...


Find one word from the story that means

move fast s ______.


State whether the following statement are true or false

The friends could not keep in touch because they lost each other’s phone numbers.


Given below are hints about a renowned British science-fiction writer Arthur C. Clarke. Write a biographical sketch on the author in not more than 80-100 words based on the information given below.

Name Arthur C. Clarke
Pen names Charles Willis, E.G.O’Brien
Birth 16 Dec 1917, England
Career novelist, television host, inventor, and film screenwriter.
Genre Science-Fiction, Television series, Film screenplay
Awards and Honours 1961, Kalinga Prize - an award given by UNESCO for popularising science Hugo and Nebula Awards Chairman of the Interplanetary Society Highest Civil Honour of Sri Lanka – ‘Sri Lankabhimanya 2005’
Titles Clarke, Robert Heinlein, and Isaac Asimov – ‘Big Three’ of Science Fiction ‘The Prophet of the Space Age’
Famous Works Childhood’s End 2001: A Space Odyssey Rendezvous with Rana

You come across an advertisement in the newspaper. A Publishing House in Chennai has brought out a paperback edition of the complete works of Khushwant Singh. You want to buy it. You are asked to send a Demand Draft for Rs.1000/- Fill in the following challan for the DD in favour of ‘X Publishing House, New Delhi’, payable at Chennai. The surcharge for Rs.1000/- is Rs.25/-.


Why according to Maya Angelou, does the caged bird sing?


You are the editor of your school magazine. You want to bring about awareness among the students on the topic -Noise Pollution: A threat to all life forms. Write an article in about 300 words based on the following points:

Causes of noise pollution - effects on humans - effects on other living creatures - measures to reduce noise pollution - role of authorities - conclusion. 


In your opinion what things will help to make the world a better place? Discuss with your friends and write down at least three of the things.


Write a composition (in approximately 400-450 words) on the following subject:

During the summer break, you joined a group of young people who read to the elderly at a senior citizens home. Narrate your experience of reading to the elderly and the interactions you had with them. How did this experience impact you?


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×