मराठी

Despite being a half monster and half human, Caliban comes across as superior to Stephano and Trinculo. Justify the statement with supporting evidence from the Acts studied in 200-250 words. - English Literature

Advertisements
Advertisements

प्रश्न

Despite being a half monster and half human, Caliban comes across as superior to Stephano and Trinculo. Justify the statement with supporting evidence from the Acts studied in 200-250 words.

दीर्घउत्तर
Advertisements

उत्तर

In "The Tempest," Caliban, despite his supposed monster nature, frequently displays features that suggest he is more analytical and observant than Stephano and Trinculo, who are purportedly 'civilised' men. This disparity is prominently reflected in their interactions and plans on the island.

First and foremost, Caliban understands the island better than Stephano and Trinculo. He possesses an intuitive understanding of the island's natural resources and geography, which he uses to navigate and survive. For example, in Act II, Scene II, he appropriately explains the island's characteristics and resources to Stephano, offering to show him "the best springs" and promising to take him to "clustering filberts." This practical understanding demonstrates his adaptability and survival instincts, which Stephano and Trinculo lack as they navigate their surroundings.

Furthermore, Caliban's attempt to overthrow Prospero exhibits a level of sophistication and strategic thinking that Stephano and Trinculo lack. Caliban persuades Stephano to assassinate Prospero in Act III, Scene II, presenting a thorough plot to catch him sleeping and grab his magical books. Caliban is the mastermind here, demonstrating his ability to influence and lead action to achieve his intended outcome, as opposed to Stephano and Trinculo's intoxicated folly and lack of foresight.

Furthermore, Caliban's knowledge of his own captivity and longing for liberation demonstrate a depth of character and grasp of his surroundings that Stephano and Trinculo lack. He sees Prospero's power as oppressive and desires release, expressing deep feelings about his situation in various monologues that reflect on his sense of self and individuality.

Caliban's superior knowledge of the island, strategic scheming, and reflective comprehension of his own predicament all point to a higher level of character depth and competence than Stephano and Trinculo's more superficial, self-serving, and buffoonish behaviour. These parts of his character call into question traditional notions of 'monstrosity' and 'humanity', presenting him as a shockingly superior figure in many ways.

shaalaa.com
Writing Skills
  या प्रश्नात किंवा उत्तरात काही त्रुटी आहे का?
2023-2024 (March) Official

APPEARS IN

संबंधित प्रश्‍न

What arc the poetic devices used in Maya Angelou’s poem “Caged Bird”?


The air broke into a mist with bells,
The old walls rocked with the crowd and cries.
Had I said, "Good folk, mere noise repels....
But give me your sun from yonder skies!"
They had answered "And afterward, what else?"

Read the above lines and answer the question that follow.

What did the patriot want form the “Good folks”?


Don John:

Fie, fie, they are not to be nam'd my lord, not to speak of, There is not chastity enough in language Without offence to utter them. Thus, pretty lady, I am sorry for thy much misgovernment. 

Claudio:

O, Hero! What a Hero hadst thou been If half thy outward graces had been plac'd About thy thoughts and counsels of thy heart! But fare thee well, most foul, most fair; farewell Thou pure impiety and impious purity For thee I'll lock up all the gates of love, And on my eyelids shall conjecture hang To turn all beauty into thoughts of harm, And never shall it more be gracious. 

(i) Where are the speakers? What leads Claudio to speak in this manner? 
(ii) What are the charges levelled against Hero by Don Pedro? 
(iii) Explain the lines:

"What an I lero hadst thou been If half thy outward graces had been plac'd About thy thoughts and counsels of thy heart!" 
(iv) What are the immediate reactions of Leonato and Hero to Claudio's words? 
(v) What impressions do we form about Leonato in this scene? 
(vi) Give the meanings of the following words as they are used in the context of the passage: misgovernment; impiety; conjecture 


Read the extract given below and answer the questions that follow:
The woods are lovely, dark and deep.
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep.
And miles to go before I sleep.
(Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening: Robert Frosty)

(i) Who is ‘I’ referred to in the extract? Which season of the year is it? What evidence is there in the poem to support your answer? 

(ii) Who has made him aware of his mistake? How does it make the speaker aware of his mistake? What does it seem to say? 

(iii) What are the three sounds heard? 

(iv) What has been said earlier by the poet about the owner of the woods? 

(v) What does lovely, dark and deep suggest? What is the underlying significance in the repetition of the last two lines of the extract? Mention the moral tag that the poet attaches to the poem. 


Join the following sentence to make one complete sentence without using and, but or so.  

They bought a new car. They can travel long distances.


The dominant colour in the poem.


Find out about as many Indian schools of painting as you can. Write a short note on the distinctive features of each school.


Distinguish between the following pairs of sentences.

The team played the two matches successfully.


How does the author succeed in raising crucial social issues not through open criticism but through subtle suggestion?


What do you understand the character of Mrs. Croft from the story?


Do you have a ‘dream’, or something you very much wish to do? Write a paragraph saying what you want or wish to do. Then say (in another paragraph) how you think you can make your dream come true.


What is beauty? Where can, in the poet’s opinion, beauty be seen, heard, and experienced?


Describe in about 150 words your experience similar to the writer’s when you pursued something and reached your goal.


Imagine that Revathi’s father is abroad on business and she wishes to convey the news of her prize - winning plants. Draft an email for the above subject.

(Use an email format.)


Would you like to join the Indian Army/Navy/ Air force? If not, suggest other ways in which you could serve your nation.


Write what you think about the following thoughts and actions of Mathilde :

Mathilde despaired over the loss of her necklace.


In the play, two devices that make use of wheels are given. The devices are:

  1. _______________
  2. _______________

From the internet or other sources, trace the history of the use of the wheel. Write ‘An Autobiography of a Wheel’.


Write your own interpretation of the story.


Prepare an announcement for an occasion like the one mentioned.


Write a short essay on your own journey in a boat.


You happen to meet a successful person who is a disabled. Write an imaginary dialogue between you and him/her. You can take support of the hints provided.

  1.  introduction/welcome/greetings
  2. congratulating/honouring 
  3. cause/reason for the disability
  4. decision/plan/organisation/implementation
  5. idols in life
  6. parents/friends - support if any
  7. success stories/accomplishments
  8. conclusion/final message if any

Write a newspaper article in about 100 words, comparing the achievements of the two sportswomen based on the information you have already collected.


Which country would you like to visit when you grow up?

Make a project by drawing or pasting.

  1. a map of that country, its national flag
  2. stamps of the country, its currency
  3. some famous monuments or landmarks

State whether the following statement are true or false

The friends grew up together in the city of New York.


State whether the following statement are true or false

Jimmy grew a little taller after he was twenty.


How did Woman 5 spend her time in the waiting hall?


Why had Miss Meadows chosen 'A Lament' as the lesson that particular day?


Answer the following question as briefly as possible and with close reference to the relevant text.

Referring closely to the short story, The Sound Machine, describe the encounter between Klausner and Mrs. Saunders. How did it affirm his belief in his own invention?


What makes you laugh?


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×