Advertisement Remove all ads

Principle: Everyone Has the Right of Private Defence to Defend His Body and Property by Use of Reasonable Force Unless that Person Had Time to Have Recourse to the Protection of Public Authorities. - Legal Reasoning

Question

MCQ

Principle: Everyone has the right of private defense to defend his body and property by use of reasonable force unless that person had time to have recourse to the protection of public authorities.

Facts: X receives information at 5.00 pm that Y along with few friends are planning to burn his crop at midnight which is ready to be harvested. He does not inform the village Police Station which was just one kilometer away. He gathers his family members and directs them to collect some weapons in the form of swords and lathis to protect his field/crop. At around 11.00 pm Y and his aides attack the crop and a severe fight ensues wherein Y is seriously injured. 

Options

  • X is not liable as he was exercising his right of private defence 

  • X and his family are not liable for the injuries caused as they were exercising the right of private defence 

  • X is liable 

  • X and his family is liable as they have not informed the police 

Solution

X and his family is liable as they have not informed the police

Explanation:

X and his family are liable as they have not informed the police. According to the principle, the right to private defence ceases if the person using this right has the time to take help of the authorities. In this case, the police station is only 1 km away and there is a clear 6 to  7 hours to seek the help of the police.   

Concept: Law of Torts (Entrance Exams)
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
Advertisement Remove all ads
Advertisement Remove all ads
Advertisement Remove all ads
Share
Notifications

View all notifications
Login
Create free account


      Forgot password?
View in app×