PUC Karnataka Science Class 12Department of Pre-University Education, Karnataka
Share

Books Shortlist
Your shortlist is empty

# The reaction, Cr2O3+2Al→Al2O3+2Cr (△Gθ=−421kJ)Cr2O3+2Al→Al2O3+2Cr (△Gθ=-421kJ) is thermodynamically feasible as is apparent from the Gibbs energy value. Why does it not take place at room temperature? - PUC Karnataka Science Class 12 - Chemistry

ConceptApplication of Thermodynamic Principles of Metallurgy

#### Question

The reaction,

Cr2O3 + 2Al → Al2O3 + 2Cr

(ΔGθ = -421kJ) is thermodynamically feasible as is apparent from the Gibbs energy value.  Why does it not take place at room temperature?

#### Solution 1

The change in Gibbs energy is related to the equilibrium constant, K as

triangleG = -RTInK

At room temperature, all reactants and products of the given reaction are in the solid state. As a result, equilibrium does not exist between the reactants and the products. Hence, the reaction does not take place at room temperature. However, at a higher temperature, chromium melts and the reaction takes place.

We also know that according to the equation

triangleG = triangleH-TtriangleS

Increasing the temperature increases the value of  TtriangleS making the value of triangleG more and more negative. Therefore, the reaction becomes more and more feasible as the temperature is increased.

#### Solution 2

This is explained on the basis of Keq, the equilibrium constant. In the given redox reaction, all reactants and products are solids at room temperature, so, there is no equilibrium between the reactants and products and hence the reactions does not occur at RT. At high temperature, Cr melts and values of TAS increases. As a result, the value of triangle_rG^theta becomes more negative and hence the reaction proceeds rapidlyt

Is there an error in this question or solution?

#### APPEARS IN

NCERT Solution for Chemistry Textbook for Class 12 (2015 to Current)
Chapter 6: General Principles and Processes of Isolation of Elements
Q: 3 | Page no. 157
Solution The reaction, Cr2O3+2Al→Al2O3+2Cr (△Gθ=−421kJ)Cr2O3+2Al→Al2O3+2Cr (△Gθ=-421kJ) is thermodynamically feasible as is apparent from the Gibbs energy value. Why does it not take place at room temperature? Concept: Application of Thermodynamic Principles of Metallurgy.
S